Eurydice (eurydice72) wrote,
Eurydice
eurydice72

I got sucked in even when I knew I shouldn't

My half-sister is an anti-vaxxer with a 2 y/o daughter. She is going nuts on Facebook, posting all these anti-vaxxer memes. It was so bad that I had to unfollow her a while back. I still check in regularly just to see what's going on, but tonight I cracked and responded to one of her damn memes. She was invoking VAERS and all the deaths that have already been reported this year as justification of her cause. I kept it as factual as I could with this:

"VAERS is not reliable for determining causality, since it's a passive reporting system. That means anyone can report. Even people who might have only read about it on the Internet. It also very clearly states that its data does not imply causality. Just because X is followed by Y does not mean X caused Y. To assume so is a logical fallacy (post hoc fallacy)."

Because I know that arguing with her about her beliefs is like talking to a wall. She isn't going to hear me. She's cherry-picking the data she looks at and ignoring the data she doesn't like, and then trying to make people feel bad by comparing those who "don't believe in medical choice" to Hitler, Mussolini, and Kim Jong-Un. My hope is that by sticking to facts (nothing I said was actually wrong or could be twisted to prove either side) she will at least start considering the interpretation of her data.

Those hopes are low, though. Most anti-vaxxers rely on the post hoc fallacy to justify their beliefs. I can only scream, "Correlation is not the same as causation!" so many times before my frustration wins out.
Subscribe

  • Celebrating the end of spring break

    Is it bad I'm glad my kids are done with spring break and back at school today? It was amazingly productive, despite the fact that my eyes decided to…

  • A pretty good Wednesday

    Ohmigod, Flonase has made such a difference. I felt better yesterday morning, but there was still lingering pain, but today? Nada. Zilch. I feel…

  • Schedule, schedule

    Next week this time, I'll be in San Antonio. I leave on Wednesday to attend a conference which ends in an awards banquet where one of my novellas is…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 11 comments

  • Celebrating the end of spring break

    Is it bad I'm glad my kids are done with spring break and back at school today? It was amazingly productive, despite the fact that my eyes decided to…

  • A pretty good Wednesday

    Ohmigod, Flonase has made such a difference. I felt better yesterday morning, but there was still lingering pain, but today? Nada. Zilch. I feel…

  • Schedule, schedule

    Next week this time, I'll be in San Antonio. I leave on Wednesday to attend a conference which ends in an awards banquet where one of my novellas is…