Eurydice (eurydice72) wrote,
Eurydice
eurydice72

American Idol



1. Phil Philips: What a great song choice for him. And how great to see him without his guitar. I enjoyed this. I don't know how long ago his surgery was, a couple days or five, but he seemed in fine form.

2. Jessica Sanchez: I was worried about the song choice, but damn if she didn't nail this. This one wasn't about sounding pretty. It was about nailing those rat-a-tat lyrics and working the stage. And *that* she did 200%.

3. Hee-Jun Han: Okay, I'll cop to it. This damn Richard Marx song is a guilty pleasure. It takes me straight back to college and late nights in the dorm and...well, I have very fond memories of this song, lol. I thought Hee-Jun was a little breathier than normal, and I can't say that I liked how he mixed it up a little, but it was still pretty.

4. Elise Testone: Much better than last week. That rasp won't get her to the finale, but at least she's proven she belongs here.

5. Deandre Brackensick: I still don't like this kid. And this song feels like cheating because it wasn't originally out that year. Yuck.

6. Shannon Magrane: While this seems a better performance than last week, she's not Mariah. Now, I am *really* not a Mariah fan, but even I prefer the Mariah version to this.

7. Colton Dixon: Okay, fangirl in me is kind of squeeing that my favorite this year has a fan in one of my favorite AI contestants ever. Daughtry and Colton together? How fab is that. :) And you know, this would've been smack dab in the middle of college and I do not know this song. I don't think that'll hurt Colton this week, though. His fanbase will enjoy the performance. I sure did.

8. Erika Van Pelt: I like her voice, but I really didn't like the arrangement. It felt all over the place.

9. Skylar Laine: Bonnie Raitt is a good fit for Skylar, and she did well with this, but it just wasn't very wow. She's not going anywhere.

10. Joshua Ledet: I don't like this song, I'll admit, but...damn. Joshua made me love it. I think shedding his coat was kind of hokey, but man, he just *blasted* that. My favorite of the night.

11. Hollie Cavanagh: Not surprised it's a big ballad again (and can I say how glad I am that I was right about her parents not being American, lol? I've been arguing with Alicia about her accent for weeks now.) It was a solid, enjoyable performance, very mature. A good way to end the show.

My top 3: Joshua, Hollie, Colton
My bottom 3: Deandre, Shannon, Erika

About Jermaine...I'm sad, I'll admit it. I liked him. So disappointed this happened, but rules are rules.

I'm off tomorrow to San Antonio for the weekend. It's a writing con but I plan on relaxing and having fun. I'll get online when I can to keep up on stuff. :)
Tags: american idol
Subscribe

  • Me and my girl

    I hate getting my picture taken. HATE. When the kids were little, I avoided doing it as often as I could. I regret that now. Life is too short, and I…

  • My brilliant daughter

    We're at the airport to head home, but I have time to get on LJ finally and post about how Alicia did. She came in 2nd place in her category, woo…

  • Safely in Cambridge

    We are safely ensconced in our hotel in Cambridge, Massachusetts, helping Alicia finish putting together her visual presentation. Registration is at…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 3 comments