Eurydice (eurydice72) wrote,
Eurydice
eurydice72

American Idol, top 12 boys



1. Todrick Hall - Kelly Clarkson? Really? He didn't just mix it up, it sounded like he completely rewrote it. And he couldn't sustain the chorus to keep it interesting. I do think he's a natural performer, though. He knows how to play to the audience.

2. Aaron Kelly - Aw, he sounded so nervous tonight. He's such a sweet kid, but between wavering, picking a really boring song, and sounding nasally, it just wasn't a good performance.

3. Jermaine Sellers - Painful. So painful. Can he be gone already, please?

4. Tim Urban - His falsetto was painful. That seems to be the word of the night. The rest of it wasn't bad, but I kept comparing it to other versions and he just fell short every time.

5. Joe Munoz - More nerves and a bad chorus. He didn't get a lot of airtime, but I don't think it's going to matter. That performance is not going to demand that the audience vote for him.

6. Tyler Grady - An interesting song choice. Tyler needs to be fronting a band. That's all there is to it. I think he'll fly through this week.

7. Lee DeWyze - I'm not keen on the song, and the performance wasn't perfect, but it was the best one yet. Which considering how bad the other guys have been, doesn't say much.

8. John Park - I didn't like the beginning. But as soon as he took that microphone off the stand, he just lit up. He can stay. :)

9. Michael Lynche - The vocals aren't perfect, but with his personality, it didn't matter. This was the most exuberant performance of the night.

10. Alex Lambert - Another one I have no idea how he made it to the top 24. I just don't like the tone of his voice. At all. And he still reminds me of Hannah Montana's older brother. :P

11. Casey James - His voice was a tiny bit shaky from nerves in parts, and the smiling was a little too much but considering what he saw at the beginning, I'm impressed with how he kept it together. I really liked it. He's going to fly through.

12. Andrew Garcia - None of the other contestants have Andrew's polish. Even for as serious as this was, it was still miles ahead of most everybody else tonight.

MY FAVORITE THREE
1. Casey
2. Andrew
3. Michael

MY BOTTOM TWO
1. Jermaine
2. Alex

WHO I THINK IS GOING HOME
Jermaine and Tim. I think Tim blew his second chance big time tonight. Alex might last another week unfortunately.
Tags: american idol
Subscribe

  • BTVS S5, Eps 17

    Only time for one episode tonight. Forever Favorite Lines Dawn: You need me, Spike. Somebody's gotta get the egg while you distract the Ghora.…

  • BTVS S5, Eps 14-16

    We are back to watching Buffy! Yay for having free time! Crush Favorite Lines Joyce: Honey, did you somehow, unintentionally, lead him on in any…

  • BTVS S5, Eps 12-13

    Craig was finally home tonight for us to watch a couple more Buffy eps. I've missed it and got completely sucked in, so my commentary is a little…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 3 comments