Eurydice (eurydice72) wrote,
Eurydice
eurydice72

American Idol, the top 5



Jason #1 - I thought Jason would have it easier tonight, because these kind of songs seem right up his alley. But this first number was just...boring. There wasn't anything wrong with his singing, but it just didn't sparkle.

David C. #1 - I don't know when this song was originally written, but David made it sound current. Much better than Jason, and I think the contrast between the two is exactly why Jason isn't going to win.

Brooke #1 - Too low for her. This just didn't sound good to me. I wanted the whole song to be higher.

David A. #1 - I think I'm over David A., too. Tonight, all I could see was that same hand gesture he uses in all the songs. I don't know why it bored me so much. Better than Jason's first, though.

Syesha #1 - I feel bad for Syesha, because I think even though this was a lovely performance, I think it's pretty much guaranteed she's going home this week. Which is a shame because she totally sang circles around everybody else except David Cook so far.

Jason #2 - Oh, this was so much nicer than his first choice. Nothing exciting, but more heartfelt.

David C. #2 - I think his first song was better, though this - again - shows exactly why he deserves to be in the finals.

Brooke #2 - She wrote the lyric on her hand?!? She's playing the piano! When does she think she's going to read it? Well. At least it was better than that first song.

David A. #2 - Not surprised in the slightest that he sang this song. I wish I could stop staring at his hand. Though I liked this one better than the first.

Syesha #2 - Some of the vocals were a little shaky, but she actually *performed*.

MY BOTTOM TWO - Jason and Brooke
MY FAVORITE TWO - David C. and Syesha

Who do I think will be bottom 2 tomorrow? Jason and Syesha, and I fear Syesha's number is up. Which is a shame because she deserves to stay longer than Jason at this point.
Tags: american idol
Subscribe

  • Snowflake Challenge #6

    Challenge #6 In your own space, rec at least three fanworks that you didn’t create. Well, one of my goals was to rec on Saturdays, which I did…

  • Saturday recs

    One of my goals this year is to rec fanfic that I really enjoy. I don't read just BtVS or Merlin. There's a whole lot more than that. I haunt…

  • Humans fic recs

    So I dipped my toe in the Humans fic over at AO3. And just dipped. I didn't want to read anything that wasn't complete, which frankly didn't leave a…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 10 comments

  • Snowflake Challenge #6

    Challenge #6 In your own space, rec at least three fanworks that you didn’t create. Well, one of my goals was to rec on Saturdays, which I did…

  • Saturday recs

    One of my goals this year is to rec fanfic that I really enjoy. I don't read just BtVS or Merlin. There's a whole lot more than that. I haunt…

  • Humans fic recs

    So I dipped my toe in the Humans fic over at AO3. And just dipped. I didn't want to read anything that wasn't complete, which frankly didn't leave a…