Phil: I actually thought he did really well with this. The song suited his voice, and he was clearly enjoying himself. That coat was awful, though.
Jordin: Not my favorite performance of hers. I wanted her to rock this one out, and it just didn't happen for me.
Lakisha: Why have I never heard this song before? Better than Jordin, but, and I can't believe I'm saying this, but Phil is still the best so far of the night. I loved the attitude of the end, but the first half wasn't nearly as good as the second.
Blake: On a purely superficial note, LOVE the black hair. And I have to say, for all of Bon Jovi's misgivings, this TOTALLY worked for me. LOVED this. Love Blake.
Chris: Some of the notes hurt me. Can he leave, please?
Melinda: She's not going anywhere. What the hell was she worried about? I loved the attitude. The woman owns the stage every time she gets up there.
You know what saddens me? Based on this week's performances, I have to say that Chris and Jordin should go home. The other 4 were just far too solid in comparison. Now, I'd love to have Jordin stay and maybe Phil go home in her place, but honestly, Phil has stepped up his game the past couple weeks. And he was way better than her tonight.